Mail-in shoe & boot repair services compared
Last checked: Nov 18, 2026 · Prices, turnaround and shipping terms quoted from each service's own pages.
Quick picks from what's published. Own Allen Edmonds, Red Wing or Danner? The maker's program posts a fixed price ($150, $165 and $100–$140 respectively). Any other brand: NuShoe posts all-in packages from $95 with a provided FedEx label and a 3–6 week wait; Wyatt & Dad and McFarland post premium leather options but Wyatt & Dad's posted lead time was 12 weeks.
| Service | Works on | Posted prices | Turnaround (as published) | How shipping works | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allen Edmonds Recrafting | Allen Edmonds shoes only | $150 Standard / $175 Prestige; heels only $50 | “About 4–6 weeks” from receipt | Buy online; continental-US customers get a prepaid label, or drop at an AE store | source |
| Red Wing Repair Shop | Welted Red Wing, WORX and Irish Setter boots | $165 resole; $180 Premium Repair Package; $60 heels only | Not published | Print repair form; free shipping label from customer service for services over $50, or bring to a Red Wing store | source |
| Danner Recrafting | Danner boots (uppers free of holes and major cracking) | $100–$140 resole; $280 rebuild | 4 weeks from receipt | Free shipping back to you | source |
| NuShoe | Any brand; authorized program for several brands | Executive NuCraft $95; Chairman NuCraft $125; Outdoorsman NuCraft $95 | “3 – 6 weeks” | Mail shoes with provided FedEx label | source |
| Fred's Shoe Repair (Peoria, IL) | Any brand; authorized Birkenstock repair center | Leather resole package $165–$335; Birkenstock $70–$120; belt shortening $20 | Birkenstock: approx. 2–4 weeks after arrival | Order online, ship to 3033 N. University St., Peoria, IL 61604 | source |
| Wyatt & Dad Cobbler Co. (Winston-Salem, NC) | Any brand; Goodyear welted most common | Standard leather full soles & heels $185–$390 depending on leather, heel and welts | “Current lead time: 12 weeks” (homepage) | Order online; cobbler consultation on arrival; stitchdown boots may cost more | source |
| McFarland Shoe Repair (Lakeland, FL) | Any brand | Leather full soles & rubber heels $195–$370; Birkenstock $80–$145 | Not captured on pages checked | Order/quote online; shop at 5355 South Florida Ave, Lakeland FL 33813 | source |
| Tulsa Shoe Rebuilders (Tulsa, OK) | Any brand (lists 150+ brands) | Men's full leather sole $75 & up; Birkenstock re-sole $70 & up (shipping extra) | Not captured on pages checked | Shoe Repair by Mail instructions; postage-paid bag or box available on request | source |
| B. Nelson Shoes (New York, NY) | High-grade dress shoes; also Birkenstock and cowboy boots | Packages on its order page (not captured) | “Allow 10 to 14 days for return delivery” | Printable mailing label on site | source |
| Leather Spa (New York, NY) | Shoes, boots, bags, belts | Not published on pages checked | Not published on pages checked | Mail-in service; drop-off at The UPS Store | source |
Before you ship
- Check eligibility: brand programs only work on their own brand, and Allen Edmonds and Red Wing both say prior work by other repair shops may prevent them from repairing a pair.
- Remove laces, insoles and shoe trees you want back – Allen Edmonds says it can't return them.
- Ask about up-charges for stitchdown construction or extra damage (Wyatt & Dad does a consultation after arrival).
See all posted prices in the resole cost guide.
Not listed: Unsung House (Nashville) is often recommended by owners on Reddit, but its website did not load when we checked on Nov 18, 2026, so we couldn't verify prices or terms.